Editorial
Edwin Edwards
Many of the most prominent newspaper columnists in the state have voiced their opinion that former governor Edwin Edwards has been punished enough. We share their opinions.
Every reasonable andcompassionate person in the state believes Edwards has been punished enough. At age 81, a ten-year sentence is inhumane, unconsciousable and tantamount to a death sentence. Keeping him in prison serves no useful purpose; absolutely none.
He has been in prison for over six years. Current federal guidelines provide for a maximum sentence of five years, not ten years. His marriage failed, he is broke financially, he will be 82 years old on August 7, 2009, and his health is not that good, having had a heart operation and two subsequent stint operations. More importantly, his good name and reputation have been tarnished for posterity.
There are two myths that we need to address. First, is the widespread belief, fostered by the government, that Edwards made his money in politics.
This is absolutely false. At 21 years of age and fresh out of LSU law school, he opened a little office in Crowley. In a few short years he built the largest, best and most profitable legal practice in the area.
When he moved to Baton Rouge, he continued to practice law when he was not governor and his law practice there continued to flourish.
As a student of government and as a participant in government for 50 years, he was by far the most qualified lawyer in the state to represent those people in or out of state who needed to navigate the multiple and intricate details necessary to do business in the state.
Lobbyists make hundreds of millions of dollars a year and one could argue that Edwards, due to his experience in government, was the best lobbyist in the entire state as well as the best problem solver. This is why thousands flocked to him for help and sought his advice and counsel. Those who know him know he never extorted anyone in his life.
The second myth is that government in Louisiana is corrupt and that all elected officials are crooks. This too is patently false and largely fostered by the news media. If you draw a circle around New Orleans, you eliminate 98 percent of corruption in the state.
Anyone who has done business in any other state knows that politics is the same in every state. There is no more corruption in Louisiana than any other state. True, there are some elected officials in every state who are corrupt, but the great majorities are not.
Edwards, with his powerful intellect and great skills in law and in business, could have made 20 times more money in the practice of law or in business. He loved his state and he loved serving the people in it. That was his passion; that was his mission; not the money.
He was elected to the following offices: City Council, State Senate, U. S. House of Representatives and Governor. He served in these various capacities over a 50-year period.
He is the only man in the long history of the state to have been elected four times to the office of governor. Common sense dictates that he must have done something right. Voters in this state are not stupid.
During his long tenure as an elected official in various capacities, he has done more for more people than any elected official in history. His myriad contributions are far too lengthy to mention but they include every aspect of life in the state.
Ask any college president, any school board member, any police juror, any mayor of small towns or large cities, any sheriff, any police chief or anyone else in government who served during his tenure and try to find one who will say that he did not help them.
Ask any state senator or representative in the legislature who served with him while governor, even his political foes, if he ever lied to them or failed to tell them what he could do to help or what he could not do to help them.
Ask the great majority of business people, oil people, and union people, working people, poor people, underprivileged/handicapped people and minority people if he helped them. Especially ask Black people what he did for Black people when it was not fashionable to solicit their vote because most of them didn’t vote at that time.
And if he is such a bad person, why have seven federal judges visited him in prison? Do federal judges make it a practice to visit people in prison? Why has a former governor and thousands of other people, rich and poor and of every stripe, visited him in prison, or send him mail every day or send him 200/300 Christmas cards every Christmas?
The pardon powers given the President were not provided accidentally by the Founding Fathers who wrote the Constitution. On the contrary, they specifically gave the president the sole power to overturn the conviction of anyone wrongly convicted or one sentenced too harshly by the criminal justice system, a system of checks and balances, if you will, over the awesome power of prosecutors and judges.
A group of the top Republicans and Democrats in the state began a mission to ask President Bush to pardon former Governor Edwards or commute his sentence on humanitarian grounds.
Former Republican Governor David Treen, whose impeccable honesty and integrity is above reproach, has led the mission to free Edwards. Former Senators J. Bennett Johnston and John Breaux support the mission and as most Louisianans, they clearly believe he has been punished enough.
A scientific poll by a reputable pollster indicated that people in Louisiana agreed that Edwards should be released from prison by better than a two-to-one margin, or 70 to 30 percent.
Mr. President we strongly recommend that, in your wisdom and compassion, you heed the request of the top Republicans and Democrats in our state who have joined together on behalf of former Governor Edwin Edwards.
“The qualities of mercy are not strained.”
He doesn’t deserve to be in prison one day longer.
Editorials represent the opinions of this newspaper, and not of any one individual.
Most read articles
| Headline | Published |
|---|---|
| Abbeville projects not getting done | Wed Mar 17 |
| Maurice wants to expand | Thu Mar 18 |
| Kaplan now has monthly music festival | Wed Mar 17 |
| Constable to go West | Wed Mar 17 |
| Sales tax collections down by $500,000 | Thu Mar 18 |



Digg
Reddit
Newsvine
Facebook
Google
Yahoo
The saddest part of this editorial isn't that it was written by the Meridional's sports writer; that it blames New Orleans for Louisiana's history of corruption; or even that it fails to give one solid example as to the "good works" Edwards achieved in office.
The saddest part of this editorial is that it proves how easy it will be for the next wannabe political crook to rise to power here. As long as he's a "nice guy." Right?
That said, most of the Meridional's editorials appear without a byline. So kudos for stepping up and not just shoving another nameless, front-page Louisiana State Newspapers Inc. editorial down our throats.
I did not write the Edwin Edwards editorial. The editorial came from home office. I merely posted it on the web site. Sorry for any confusion.
He will be neither the first nor the last convict to die in prison, if he should. He knew the risks. If you can't do the time, don't do the crime. It's as simple as that. People have got to stop raising this man up to be some kind of saint to Louisiana .
Edwin edwards was a very smart fellow. He was also a crook. By his own admission at one point he was the "...most investigated politician in America." His uncanny knack from avoiding prosecution or having others do his time for him (check with Buddy Roemer's Daddy!)....only served to heighten his arrogance and increase his risk taking. When finally caught with the goods and successfully prosecuted he got what he had avoided so many times before...a reasonable consequence!!!
While he may have promoted himself as a populist akin to Huey or Earl at the end of the day he was all about Edwin and what's in it for me....
The negative reputation he cast over this State, and one well enhanced by his successors in the legislature and elsewhere, continues to exact a price from the citizens of Louisiana as business and industry still shudder at the costs of "doin bizness" in Louisiana.....
On a brighter note, at least the current Illinios Govenor is taking some of the stink off of Louisiana's reputation!!
I have no doubt that there are hundreds if not thousands of men in prisons around this country who, due to age, infirmity, whatever, would engender sympathy. Should we ask for their release? Did some of them ever do any good before they went bad? probably....
No, EWE did the crime(s)...let him serve his time and, hopefully like the Old Soldier in Gen. MacArthur's farewell adress to West Point: "...just fade away."
He sold riverboat licenses. He may have been a great man up until that point. But, after that, he was nothing more than a crook.
You talk about him serving as City Councilman, State Senator, U. S. Representative and Governor. He abused the power of the Governor's office and used it for his own profit.
You talk about the business people, oil people, and union people, working people, poor people, underprivileged/handicapped people and minority people whom he helped. How did selling a gambling license help any of them? On the other hand, how many of them were hurt because companies (and therefore, jobs) fled the state because of it's corrupt appearance?
Kenneth Lay was a great business man - right up until the point where he began defrauding investors. Richard Nixon was a great President - right up until the point where he decided that committing a crime was OK because he was the President. Hitler was a great leader (restored national pride, gave voice to the middle class, etc.) - right up until he started a war and started the Holocaust.
I'm not comparing Edwards to any of these men. I'm saying that, just like every other human being, he was judged on the merits of that one action. He broke the law, and now he is doing the time.
If Mother Theresa decided to kill a few people, would it have been OK because she had helped so many before that? Would we have all looked the other way and let her skate by?
Edwin abused the power of his office, betrayed the trust of the people, and tarnished the image of the State of Louisiana. If he dies in jail, he can ask God for forgiveness, because I'm not giving it to him.